I wanted cosmic awe and got a desk full of sticky notes. So much cleverness, so little air. Every time the story built a head of steam, another smirking footnote wandered in with jam on its fingers.
The Practical Atlas is cute for a chapter, then it starts heckling the novel. It interrupts, corrects, cross-references, and turns momentum into homework. I kept flipping ahead to see when the page would stop arguing with itself.
Characters keep promising loss and consequence, yet the tone refuses to sit still. The star-sloop is allergic to metaphors, the drones sing in machine code, minutes vanish from mornings, and somehow none of it feels dangerous. The Atlantic about to fold should terrify. I felt mildly inconvenienced.
Comparisons kept bouncing around my head. Imagine a puzzle novel that loves paradox more than people, spliced with a quirky field guide that mistakes whimsy for heart. That is where this lands for me.
There are sparks. A throwaway line about the left gloves aches with possibility. Then the book sprints to a new gag. I admire the ambition, but the result is noise, and I finished tired rather than thrilled.