I walked away exasperated. The book keeps promising a blaze of revelation, then wanders into fog. Paragraph after paragraph leans on ornamental phrasing until scenes wobble, and the structure buckles under detours that feel like filler rather than momentum.
Filtering everything through an eleven-year-old should be electrifying. Instead the lens blurs key beats after the elevator fire, while talk-radio tirades sprawl over pages without modulation. The red bike, the rattling pills, the notebook of equations show up like stage dressing more than living detail.
Pacing turns punitive. We circle the same suspicions, the same chilly smiles at church, the same rumors on the county building stairs, and the chapters keep swelling as if bigger automatically means deeper. I kept checking the time and groaning.
The character work feels pinned under thesis statements. Jeremy is presented as a symbol first and a person second, Mira's father slides toward saintly, and the sheriff reads broad. Dialogue clunks when it should crackle, and scenes stall right when sparks should catch.
I wanted clarity, not a haze of Important Statements. Tighten the line edits, cut the sermonizing broadcasts, let Mira and her father share more unguarded minutes in the mill, and maybe the heart of this story would actually beat. As is, it thuds.