I came for salt-stained Maine and the intimacy of old radio, but the mystery kept elbowing its way to the front until the atmosphere thinned out. The novel keeps saying listen, and then it shouts over itself.
Compared with Ruth Moore's coastal novels and Howard Mansfield's meditations on material culture, this one leans too hard on the puzzle-box: signals here, a barometer there, a rumor pointing back to 1898. Those elements should harmonize, but the melody never settles.
Some scenes spark — the Presto cutter biting into lacquer, the transmitter humming in a whiteout — yet the connective tissue feels slack. Why are the corrugated transitions between discs, logbook, and inquest so messy when the individual beats are so precise?
It is frustrating because the ingredients are undeniably strong. I kept wanting a tide chart, not a cipher machine!
Ambition counts, and I respect the research, but the result, for me, was a persistent static that muffled what could have been a fierce, clear signal.