As a librarian who recommends literary fiction every day, I am frustrated by how this book buries its strongest idea under a drift of dust and dithering. The premise crackles, yet the narrative keeps walking in circles around the shop, opening another box instead of opening the story.
Reader advisories: labor conflict and a disappearance, family secrecy, intergenerational debt, civic pressure from developers, and a low hum of grief. None of these are handled carelessly, but the accumulation without propulsion feels punishing.
For patrons asking for Southern mill-town novels with a spectral edge, I want to say yes, take this, go. But the pacing is glacial, the meetings and murmurs outnumber movement, and the Lenore Pike thread never tightens into urgency. I could feel the hours stretching.
The whispering fabric is an evocative device that never coheres. The voices sound like foggy choruses instead of distinct history, and the ambiguity reads as indecision rather than purposeful mystery. Every time the story needed traction, the gossamer whispered and the scene faded.
I am not shelving this as a go-to. For readers who crave tactile process and small-town mood, maybe. For book clubs wanting a clear arc to argue over, no. I closed it angry at the lost potential, wishing the loom had been allowed to speak in a register sharp enough to cut.