Echoes of Indigenous Voices

Echoes of Indigenous Voices

Nonfiction · 384 pages · Published 2023-10-10 · Avg 4.3★ (6 reviews)

On a rain-blown July afternoon in 2019, a graduate assistant at the University of Montana cracked open a dented aluminum case misfiled in the music archives. Inside were twenty-three reel-to-reel tapes labeled in a neat hand: UHER 4000—Snowmelt Pass, Winter '74. When Jamison Two-Hawks threaded the first tape, he heard the trembling hum of a generator, wind screaming like a kettle, and a young woman naming the hour in Lakȟótiyapi before switching to English: "Mariah Spotted Elk, eight miles above the timberline. Quartzline skidders below us. Everyone's awake." Those recordings—made in the Bitterroot Range during a three-month blockade to halt clear-cutting on treaty-ceded slopes—unfurl an extraordinary chronicle of endurance and purpose. Families from the Confederated Salish and Kootenai, Bitterroot Salish elders, and Lakota students from Missoula caravanned to Snowmelt Pass in February 1974, hauling cedar snowshoes, canvas wall tents, and a sacred cottonwood pole lashed to a flatbed. What began as a ceremony to read aloud the unhonored promises of the 1855 Hellgate Treaty became a siege when a whiteout sealed the only switchback road. With a battery-powered ham radio (call sign W7HUM), a hand drill, a cast-iron Dutch oven, and coffee cans of rendered deer fat, they rationed flour, melted ice from blue-glazed drifts, argued by lantern light about tactics and prayer, and watched the green chains of Quartzline's mill devour the valley below. The tapes capture everything: the hiss of the stove, jokes about frozen mittens, the creak of a yew bow, the slow failing of a truck's carburetor, and the naming of the dead when a search party returned without Daniel Running Crane.

Two-Hawks follows the spooled voices across decades and terrain—from the basement of the Missoula courthouse to the pine-shadowed cemetery at Arlee; from a cardboard banker's box of Bureau of Indian Affairs memos sealed with brittle red tape to a photo negative in a Forest Service drawer stamped with an eagle and the word CONFIDENTIAL. The blockade's aftermath led to a bruising legal fight, Spotted Elk et al. v. United States, a case that drew log drivers in their lunch pails and grandmothers in ribbon skirts to Judge Lila Merriweather's courtroom. In testimony layered with maps, ledger drawings, a snow diary in pencil, and a contractor's fire plan, it became clear that more than a logging contract was at issue. A hidden memo outlined a plan to burn slash piles that would have leapt the line into a burial grove; a consultant's report had mistranslated a crucial clause about consent. Two-Hawks renders the hearing room with the taut intelligence of a legal thriller and the intimate patience of fieldwork. His reconstruction of the ridge-top camp—its hunger, its arguments over sovereignty and stewardship, its improvisations with baling wire—rivals the classics of survival narrative, yet the gravest stakes are philosophical: the idea of development, of nationhood itself, is placed under cross-examination. Echoes of Indigenous Voices braids the mechanical detail of chainsaw teeth and snowpack layers with the deep cadences of language and law, culminating in a rare injunction that still reverberates up the valley. The result is a living record that refuses to let a ruined winter, or the people who stood inside it, be tidied into the margins.

Jamison Two-Hawks (Oglala Lakota and Bitterroot Salish) is a journalist and oral historian born in 1981 in Rapid City, South Dakota, and raised between Rapid City and the Flathead Reservation in Montana. A graduate of the University of Montana (B.A., History) and the University of British Columbia (M.J., Journalism), he has reported on land rights, water policy, and language revitalization for outlets including High Country News, Montana Public Radio, and the Indigenous Media Freedom Alliance. Two-Hawks has served as a researcher for a Tribal Historic Preservation Office and taught community workshops on field recording and archival practice. His reporting has received honors from the Native American Journalists Association, and his audio projects have been exhibited at regional museums and tribal colleges. He lives in Missoula, where he mentors youth storytellers and works with elders to preserve family collections of tapes, photographs, and ledger drawings.

Ratings & Reviews

Tomo Arakawa
2025-08-30

Imagine Bad Indians by Deborah Miranda braided with the meticulous stakes of The Cold Vanish, then routed through a basement archive and a mountain pass. That is the register here, intimate and procedural, with the wind in the microphone and a judge who listens. Readers of environmental justice narratives and patient investigative nonfiction will find something rare and necessary.

Colin Brantley
2025-04-18
  • Magnetic archival moments on tape
  • Occasional drag in courtroom minutiae
  • Clear scene geography on the ridge
  • Some repetition in the consent debate
Esperanza Leclerc
2024-12-01

This book asks who gets to define progress, and on what timeline. The blockade becomes an inquiry into reciprocity as law and land speak back to each other. A single phrase frames it for me, when the camp gathers to "read aloud the unhonored promises" and refuses to let procedural language erase ceremony. By the time the rare injunction arrives, development itself has been put on the witness stand, and the echo of that decision feels less like closure and more like a vow.

Aisha Ncube
2024-07-22

What lingers are the people, from Mariah Spotted Elk timing the dawn to Jamison Two-Hawks threading voices across years, to elders who argue by lantern light and students who learn to balance tactics and prayer.

Kendrick Salazar
2024-03-08

Wind howls, the generator trembles, and that first voice naming the hour lands like a flare over Snowmelt Pass. I felt the tapes in my bones. The UHER reels, the kettle scream, the careful timekeeping in Lakȟótiyapi, the radio call sign cutting through static, all of it charges the air with purpose.

The camp is more than a setting. It is a system with rules and risks, from deer fat in coffee cans to the yew bow creaking in the cold. When the book uncovers a memo about slash piles near a burial grove and a mistranslated clause about consent, the stakes blaze into view.

In court, the presence is tactile. Lunch pails and ribbon skirts, maps and ledger drawings, a snow diary in pencil; Judge Lila Merriweather holding steady while the language of the land argues with the language of the contract. It is tense, humane, exacting, and yes, electric.

Two-Hawks moves like a careful climber, roping scenes across decades, keeping slack to let voices breathe. Sovereignty, stewardship, and development are not abstract topics here, they are daily decisions taken with cold hands and bright minds.

I finished with my heart pounding. This is a living record that refuses to be tidied, a book I will press into hands again and again, because its injunction still echoes up the valley and, astonishingly, into us. Yes.

Maya Routh
2023-11-15

The structure is elegantly braided: recovered reels, shoe-leather archive work, and a lucid legal chronicle. Two-Hawks favors a patient rhythm, with long sentences that ease into lists of exact objects, then snap to a clean declarative when a revelation lands.

A few stretches lean too hard on exhibit summaries and agency acronyms, which flatten the pulse. Still, the prose carries a steady authority, and the transitions between snowbound camp and courtroom keep their orientation even when the clouds roll in.

Generated on 2025-09-16 09:03 UTC